Substitutions

Substitutes A12 and B12 properly enter the game between downs.  The replaced player of A remains in the team huddle while the replaced B player leaves the field immediately.




__________________________________




Ruling: In this situation, A is charged with a 5-yard dead-ball foul for an illegal substitution because the replaced player of A did not leave immediately as required.(3.7.1A)Casebook



Personal comment:  What if it was B that didn't leave immediately?  Would the penalty be the same or do you give B more time?  I'm curious to see how you do this.  Try our forum at http://nafoa.net/Home/PlayoftheDay/POTDForum/tabid/70/forumid/3/scope/threads/Default.aspx so we can compare how your doing this.  This is not a right or a wrong, we just want to see how you are doing this and why.